Gender and age: a report from the National Havurah Committee Institute

by: Rabbi Jill Jacobs

Mon Aug 18, 2008 at 11:02:14 AM EDT


I just returned from the National Havurah Committee's summer institute, a weeklong learning/davening/singing/chatting, etc. experience. 

The major themes of the week were gender and social justice.  (that's "gender" and "social justice"--not "gender and social justice.")  

The folks at Jewschool have written pretty extensively about the gender conversations, so I won't reprise it all.  As mentioned there, one of the major issues revolved around the different understandings of gender identities/possibilities for gender identities among folks of different backgrounds and generation.  What I found even more surprising, though, were the similarities in the gender concerns of the thirtysomethings and the sixtysomethings.  (the 40s & 50s were, by and large, the missing generation at the Institute, but more on that later.)

Rabbi Jill Jacobs :: Gender and age: a report from the National Havurah Committee Institute

These two groups spoke largely about gender imbalances at work, work-life balance, and hidden inequities in progressive communities.  In contrast, the twenty-somethings generally looked outward for examples of gender imbalance (such as talking about what they've seen in Orthodox communities). 

Why the split between the 20s & 30s, and the similarities between the 30s & 60s?  Have gender relations gotten way better in the past ten years?  Do women generally not encounter gender as a major issue until they get to a certain point in their careers, or until they start having children? Are those in their 60s thinking about the issues that their 30-something children are facing (or vice versa)?  

Speaking about age--the NHC is the only Jewish organization that I've seen that's successfully and consciously turned over leadership to the next generation.  While the original Havurahniks (now mostly in their 60s) still attend institute, serve on the board, and volunteer in many ways, the co-chairs of the institute for the past several years have been people in their 20s or early 30s.  My understanding is that this shift is largely intentional.  The original folks realized at some point that the NHC wouldn't last long if people in their 20s & 30s didn't come.  The group thus created the Everett Fellowship, which makes it financially feasible for people in their 20s and 30s to attend the Institute.  So far, this sounds like many other Jewish organizations creating programming for "young adults" or lowering prices for people under a certain age.  But--brilliantly, the NHC folks then actually turned much of the leadership over to the younger folks, rather than going the traditional route of just inviting younger people or (horrors!) creating a junior board where people under 40 can play at being board members.  The board of NHC now includes teenagers as well as people of a certain age, people in their 20s and even younger feel real ownership of the organization, and people in their 60s, 70s, 80s still come and feel at home. (as I mentioned before, there were few folks in their 40s & 50s--this is the group that seems to have gotten lost in the pre-Everett era).

 The entire community benefits from the range of experiences that this multigenerational group brings to the table.  In the class I taught, for instance, I loved hearing a 16 year old and a 60 year old exchange ideas about power, and listen to and learn from one another.  Quite a breath of fresh air in a world that tends to segregate by age.  

Tags: , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Gender and age (0.00 / 0)

Great post!

The NHC's generational shift has been an amazing success so far, and should serve as a model for other Jewish institutions.  The NHC is one of the few Jewish communities where I can interact with people of other generations as an equal, rather than being looked down on as a young whippersnapper, or being put on a pedestal as the Jewish future (and a potential maker of Jewish babies).

 

As for the gender conversation:

I'm in my late 20s, and also focused on hidden inequities in progressive communities, noting that these issues can be harder to address than more explicit inequities, because the policies on paper are already fully nondiscriminatory and exactly where they should be.  One subgenerational difference is that many people in their early 20s are recently out of college, and so experiences in often Orthodox-dominated Hillels are fresher in their minds, whereas I've been out of college for 7 years and all the communities that I've thought of as "my community" since then (the question asked for a "time when gender mattered in your community") have been fully egalitarian (at least on paper), so inequalities in Orthodox communities aren't directly relevant to my life, and I think this is true of a majority of Institute participants.  In college we all had to get along; out in the real world, we can agree to disagree (but then have to clean our own house).



what's a 20-something (0.00 / 0)
Good point, BZ.  I talked to a few people in their late 20s who noted that they either joined or wanted to join the 30s group b/c they didn't share the concerns of the people in their early 20s.  I wonder at what age gender issues start to come into focus--is 26 or 27 a breaking point?

[ Parent ]
michael jackson t-shirts for men (0.00 / 0)


User Blox 1
- Put stuff here

Barack Obama
Job Losses Graphic
by: Mae Singerman - Feb 17
2 Comments
Comparing Obama to Hitler
by: Katie Halper - Aug 26
1 Comments

Search




Advanced Search

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?

RSS Feed Links
Subscribe to JSpot in a feed reader!


Subscribe to JSPOT by Email!
User Blox 4
- Put stuff here

The views presented on jspot.org are solely those of their authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Progressive Jewish Alliance & Jewish Funds for Justice (PJA & JFSJ). PJA & JFSJ and jspot.org do not support or oppose candidates or political parties.
© 2011 Progressive Jewish Alliance & Jewish Funds For Justice. All rights reserved.

Site Design: Articulated Man
Powered by: SoapBlox