John Mayer could be giving us free concerts right now...

by: Mae Singerman

Wed Feb 10, 2010 at 13:50:19 PM EST


John Mayer is a famous musician. Here is one of his most popular romantic songs. Here’s his song about how everyone in "our generation" (whatever that means) are hopeless and waiting for someone else to do something. This song is literally an anti-anthem for any social change movement.  

He’s also a known womanizer and “half” Jewish: 

"PLAYBOY: Is your heritage Jewish?

MAYER: I’m half Jewish. People say, “Well, which side of your family is Jewish?” I say, “My dad’s.” And they always say it doesn’t count. But I will say I keep my pool at 92 degrees, so you do the math. I find myself relating to Judaism. One of my best friends is Jewish beyond all Jews—I went to my first Passover seder at his house—and I train in Krav Maga with a lot of Israelis."  *this is from the newest Playboy magazine, but I'm not going to link to it. 

Besides wishing that he wasn’t any percent Jewish, his response makes me think about my reaction when people tell me they only have one Jewish parent. I know someone whose grandmother was born Jewish, converted to Catholicism and raised his mother as Catholic. He has no connection to Jewish community or activities. Is he “more” Jewish than someone who has only a Jewish dad, but participates in many aspects of organized Jewish life? Even though John Mayer is gross, it sucks that he’s spent his whole life telling people he’s Jewish to have them correct him, even though he feels a connection to Judaism.

How many John Mayers are Jews pushing away?
Would John Mayer be less of a jerk if Jews would have accepted him?
How many free concerts could we (Jews) be getting right now, if we would have let him hang out like fifteen years ago?
Mae Singerman :: John Mayer could be giving us free concerts right now...
Tags: , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
Oh great.... (0.00 / 0)
....now we have to claim him as one of the Tribe? That's sure to get tons of screaming teenage girls through the temple doors.

John Mayer and Judaism?? (0.00 / 0)
Although we certainly cannot determine if John Mayer would be less gross if he were Jewish (btw if you read that article in Playboy, Mayer also claims to have a  a "hood" pass among black people...don't even get me started on that racist comment), I, too, have often thought about the issue of determining Jewish connections through the mother.  As a religion that is facing higher rates of assimilation and intermarriage than ever before...continuity is the buzzword that is heard over and over again.  How can we as Jews conscionably turn people away from the religion simply on the basis that their father was Jewish rather than their mother?  Is it time that we take a harder look at what makes a Jew a Jew?  Or will the chosen people continue to remain choosy, and lose a constituency in the process....

dragon ball action figure (0.00 / 0)


User Blox 1
- Put stuff here

Barack Obama
Job Losses Graphic
by: Mae Singerman - Feb 17
2 Comments
Comparing Obama to Hitler
by: Katie Halper - Aug 26
1 Comments

Search




Advanced Search

Menu

Make a New Account

Username:

Password:



Forget your username or password?

RSS Feed Links
Subscribe to JSpot in a feed reader!


Subscribe to JSPOT by Email!
User Blox 4
- Put stuff here

The views presented on jspot.org are solely those of their authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Progressive Jewish Alliance & Jewish Funds for Justice (PJA & JFSJ). PJA & JFSJ and jspot.org do not support or oppose candidates or political parties.
© 2011 Progressive Jewish Alliance & Jewish Funds For Justice. All rights reserved.

Site Design: Articulated Man
Powered by: SoapBlox